Tuesday, September 17th, was a bustling day for Manchester City chairman Richard Maddox.
The first order of business: reviewing the clubâs last three matches.
One win, one draw, and one loss.
Just four points out of a possible nineâand for now, City were sitting in 13th place in the league standings.
Richard lifted his head toward the man seated across from him.
OâNeill was back.
However, he wasnât yet fit to return to the touchline. Following his recent hip replacement surgery, the doctors had strongly advised against full involvement. For now, light participation in training sessions was the most they would allow.
"Are you sure youâre okay?" Richard asked, concern evident in his voice.
OâNeill gave a wry smile. "What choice do I have?"
Back at the Maine Road training ground, Robertson was approached by Miss Heysen.
"The Chairman wants to see you," she said. "Right nowâin his office."
Robertsonâs heart sank. He already had a feeling what this was about.
"Did he say anything else?" he asked cautiously.
She shook her head. As Robertson turned to leave, she added, "But... he looked grim."
Ba-dum. His heart thumped. That confirmed it. It had to be about
that
post-match commentâthe one where heâd said,
"We were raped by the referee."
Without wasting another second, Robertson hurried toward Richard Maddoxâs officeâlocated just above the managerâs office.
He knocked while pushing the door openâand froze.
Seated behind the large desk was Chairman Richard Maddox.
But it wasnât just him.
Also in the room, seated comfortably as if heâd never left, was none other than Martin OâNeill.
Robertson hadnât expected to see OâNeill there too. He was caught off guard for a momentâbut quickly recovered and offered a warm smile.
"Martin! Since when?!"
After exchanging greetings with Richard, Robertson immediately stepped forward and embraced OâNeill without hesitation. It was a brief moment of genuine joy between colleagues and friends.
But the small talk was cut short when Richard stood up from behind his desk, holding a sheet of paper in his hand. He walked toward Robertson with a serious expression.
Seeing the paper in Richardâs hand, Robertsonâs stomach dropped. A dozen worst-case scenarios flashed through his mind, instantly making him forget all about the disciplinary hearing.
Was this a dismissal letter? A formal warning?
He hadnât exactly been producing stellar results latelyânot after all the money City had invested and the expectations raised by their dominant First Division campaign last season.
But Richardâs calm voice pulled him out of the spiral.
"This is a fax from the Football Association," he said. "Theyâve summoned you to London tomorrow for a disciplinary hearing."
Only then did Robertson find his voice.
"...Is this about what I said after the match?"
Richard nodded.
Though it wasnât a letter of dismissal, Robertsonâs mood didnât improve. He had caused unnecessary trouble for the club, and only now did he realize just how much he had let his emotions get the better of him during the previous match against Leeds.
But then, Richardâs next words lifted a weight off Robertsonâs shoulders and made the world seem just a little brighter.
"The club will be fully supporting you," he said firmly. "Weâve already gone over everything together and submitted an official appeal to the FA."
He looked up at Richard again. The young chairman smiled and said, "Get yourself readyâyouâll be going to London with me tomorrow. But before that, I need you to meet someone."
Robertson nodded at this, and Richard patted his shoulder reassuringly. "Donât worry, the club has hired a lawyer for you. Let him handle everything."
The lawyer Richard had brought in, of course, was Adam Lewisâhis current external legal advisor for both Manchester City and the Maddox Group.
Lewis took a stack of documents out of his briefcase and placed them on the table. "Mr. Robertson, I hope you donât mind me saying this, but your final comment during the September 15th post-match press conference was... a little unwise."
Robertson immediately recalled it. "Which part? Was it about the "rape" thing?"
Lewis looked up at him and nodded. "Yes."
He then continued, "If you had only voiced your doubts or frustrations about the refereeâs performance, that wouldâve been viewed as normal post-match complaintsânothing out of the ordinary for a manager whoâd just suffered a tough loss. But it was the remark you added at the end that changed everything."
Robertson frowned slightly as Lewis continued.
"You didnât just criticize the refereeâyou implied a deeper distrust. Not just of that one official, but of the transparency and integrity of the entire English Football Association. And for the FA, thatâs a red line. That single comment is what escalated this issue."
"..."
The room fell into a tense silence before Richard finally spoke. "Is there any way out of this?"
Lewis leaned back slightly. "Based on my experience, the FA will likely ask you to clarify your remark at the hearing. If you want to avoid a harsher punishment, youâll need to convince them that your comments werenât aimed at the FA itself."
Robertson let out a quiet sigh. "Honestly, I was never against the FA. It was just that referee..."
"Thereâs no point in saying that to me," Lewis replied calmly. "You need to make
them
believe that. And that wonât be easy."
He paused, then added, "Let me give you some context. When Keith Wiseman succeeded Sir Bert Millichip as chairman of the FA, he promised to clean up English footballâno more scandals, no tolerance for misconduct. Heâs been working to rebuild the FAâs reputation. And your comment, whether intended or not, suggested that the FA isnât as clean as it claims to be."
"Butâ"
"Save your words for the FA. Whether you meant it or not, after the media blew it out of proportion, everyone now believes you did." OâNeill, the experienced one, chimed in.
Robertson understood all too well the power of the English media. Grabbing his head with both hands, he groaned softly, "Those bloody media bastards..."
In other words, this whole mess had been dragged out because of them.
Seeing his reaction, Lewis simply shrugged. "Only realizing that now? But there are pros and cons to using your current status in how we handle this."
"My status?" Robertson asked, confused.
Lewis glanced at Edwards before turning back to Robertson. "Manchester City isnât the same old club just surviving in the Premier League. Yes, youâve just been promoted, and the derby against United brought a lot of attentionâbut at the end of the day, you still lost. In other words, Cityâs influence in English football is still relatively small."
"And what does that mean for me?"
"It means the FA might not take you seriouslyâand that could work in your favor. They might let it slide with a warning, thinking itâs just frustration from a lower-profile club. Or," Lewis paused, "they could use this as an opportunity to make an example out of you. Wiseman wants to send a message, and you might be the one to carry it."
The room went quiet. Everyone understood the implication. If this were Manchester Unitedâor if Robertson were someone with Fergusonâs statureâthe FA might tread more carefully, weighing the political and media consequences. But for City? And for a manager still building his name? They were easy targets.
Lewis let the silence settle before continuing. He reached into his briefcase and pulled out a thick document, placing it on the table with a soft thud.
"So, hereâs what youâre going to do," he said calmly. "This is a scriptâa guide, really. It covers the possible questions the FA might throw at you, along with the recommended responses. Youâll need to study this carefully before we leave for London."
Robertson stared at the thick file as if it had just handed him a death sentence.
For a moment, the weight of it all made him feel like giving up. But eventually, with a long sigh, he nodded and picked up the document.
"Alright," he muttered. "Letâs do this."